Women’s Health & Hormones

Proactive HRT: Why I Prescribe Hormones in Phases

Perimenopause unfolds in stages. Here’s how I use baseline testing and phase progesterone, estradiol and testosterone as symptoms and hormone needs change.

A phased hormone therapy plan that changes as a woman moves through perimenopause.

Robin's Short Version

  • Perimenopause unfolds in stages: progesterone often shifts before estrogen declines consistently.
  • Robin begins with baseline labs and cycle tracking, then adds hormones only as symptoms and physiology change.
  • Progesterone may be considered first for early changes involving sleep, anxiety, acne or cycles; estradiol and testosterone are separate, later decisions.
  • Hormone type, delivery method, dose and follow-up all matter, so plans should be reassessed every 3–6 months at first.
  • Healthy women who are under 60 or within 10 years of menopause generally have the most favorable benefit-risk window for HRT.

Your hormones don't all drop at once. Your symptoms build over time. So why does HRT so often start with one default prescription?

I started progesterone before I had a single hot flash. I was 45, noticing hormonal acne around my period, a classic sign of a progesterone-androgen imbalance, and my sleep was increasingly interrupted in the second half of my cycle.

But, my cycle was still like clockwork. I had no signs of brain fog, abdominal weight gain or vaginal dryness. My hormone labs looked good.

I'm not on systemic estrogen. I'm not on testosterone. Not yet. That's on purpose.

Most women get HRT one of two ways. They wait until symptoms are unbearable, then get handed a standard dose. Or they get told they're "too young" and sent home. Neither one matches how hormones actually change.

Perimenopause happens in stages. Different hormones shift at different times. So I prescribe in phases. Start early, start light, and layer in only what your body needs, when it needs it.

Sleeping badly, more anxious, cycles getting weird in your late 30s or 40s? That's exactly where I'd want to start mapping your hormones. Let's build your plan →

This week: how I phase HRT, and how to have this conversation with your doctor.

⚡ Forward this protocol

The Phased HRT Protocol:

Proactive doesn't mean hormones for everyone. It means a plan before a crisis.

1️⃣ Baseline (mid-30s): labs and cycle tracking, before anything changes.

2️⃣ Cyclic topical or vaginal progesterone first (early perimenopause): for sleep, anxiety, acne and heavier or irregular cycles.

3️⃣ Layer in estradiol (later perimenopause and menopause): patch or gel preferred, low dose, titrated. Switch to consistent oral progesterone (no more topical or suppositories once you’re on estrogen).

4️⃣ Add testosterone if needed: based on symptoms like low libido and labs.

5️⃣ Re-check every 3–6 months: your dose should change as you do; ensure you’re absorbing and meeting target estrogen levels

👉 Forward this to the friend who's been told she's "too young" for hormones.

What to know: Perimenopause isn't one event. It's a sequence.

❌ The old assumption: Menopause = low estrogen. Replace the estrogen.

The new reality: Progesterone often goes first.

In the early transition, cycle length starts shifting by 7+ days1. More cycles skip ovulation. No ovulation means less progesterone. Meanwhile, estrogen swings, and can even run higher than before. That's often when sleep, anxiety and heavy periods show up, while your period is still coming.

In a randomized trial, oral micronized progesterone at bedtime improved sleep and night sweats in perimenopausal women2. No estrogen needed.

❝ Adding estrogen to a body that isn't low on estrogen yet doesn't fix the problem.

Estrogen comes later, and how you take it matters.

As you move toward menopause, estrogen drops for real. That's when hot flashes, brain fog, abdominal weight gain, joint pain and vaginal dryness tend to arrive. Through the skin is my default. Oral estrogen raised blood clot risk 58%. Patches and gels showed no increase3. That said there are times when oral estrogen is appropriate - not everyone absorbs hormones through the skin the same way.

The type of progesterone matters too.

In 54,548 French women, estrogen plus synthetic progestins raised breast cancer risk 40%. Estrogen plus micronized progesterone, the same molecule your ovaries make, showed no increase4. It's observational. We still need an RCT. But it's why I use bioidentical progesterone.

Testosterone is its own decision.

It declines more gradually, and not every woman needs it. The best evidence is for low libido after menopause5.

Starting earlier is the point.

Benefits outweigh risks for healthy women under 60, or within 10 years of menopause6. Proactive means you're already working with your doctor when you reach that window. Not scrambling to start.

What to do: Phase it, personalize it, re-check it.

This is how I think about it with my patients. Your plan should change as your hormones do.

1️⃣ Phase 1: Get a baseline (mid-30s).

No single lab can diagnose perimenopause. Hormones swing too much day to day. But a baseline gives you a personal reference point, and rules out the things that mimic perimenopause.

  • Estradiol, progesterone, FSH, total and free testosterone
  • Thyroid panel, ferritin, fasting insulin, lipids
  • Track your cycle length and symptoms - bonus to add HRV and sleep data through your Whoop

2️⃣ Phase 2: Start with progesterone.

When sleep, anxiety or cycles start to shift.

  • I use 50 mg of compounded topical progesterone cream. I'm not on estrogen, so this lighter form works for my symptoms right now. I use it in the second half of my cycle only, so as not to interrupt my cycle. The goal is to address luteal phase sleep disruptions and acne.
  • Once I add estrogen, I'll switch to oral progesterone. Topical cream or vaginal suppositories are for symptoms. They aren’t proven (yet) to reliably protect the uterine lining once estrogen is in the mix7.

3️⃣ Phase 3: Layer in estradiol.

When hot flashes, brain fog, joint pain or vaginal dryness show up, or labs show estrogen is truly low.

  • Patch or gel preferred but some poor skin-absorbers do better with oral
  • Start low, then titrate every few months
  • Always include (or vaginal) micronized progesterone if you have a uterus
  • Compound when you need “in between” doses to match your symptoms when standard doses don’t hit the mark

4️⃣ Phase 4: Add testosterone, if needed.

For low libido, or muscle loss despite strength training. (The muscle piece is my clinical judgment, not yet a guideline.)

  • Transdermal only, at female doses
  • Watch for acne irritability or hair growth

5️⃣ Always: re-check and screen.

  • Check levels: target estradiol > 50 for bone protection
  • Assess symptoms and dosing every 3–6 months at first, then yearly
  • Mammogram at least every other year from 408
  • Bone density baseline age 35
  • Full body DEXA annually

The goal: The right hormone, at the right time, at the right dose. For your body. Not a default.

Which phase are you in? Hit reply and tell me. I read every one.

Living Longevity

I’m deep in the fall conference circuit. This week I’m writing from HLTH, the Super Bowl of healthcare conferences, held in Las Vegas every year. It feels like the opposite of Eudēmonia. This one is for the industry: insurance companies, big hospital systems, lots of startups and investors. All the machinery that makes our healthcare system run, grow and evolve.

It’s a fascinating event, and I always meet super interesting people. Last night I went to dinner with a group of incredible women in healthcare, and I was so inspired by what they’re working on:

  • making menopause care available
  • improving women’s postpartum experience
  • getting in-home primary care to women on Medicaid
  • expanding access and education around contraception

At something this big, it’s tempting to be cynical. But what really touches me is how many incredible people are working to make our healthcare system better, in women’s health and beyond.

I also loved talking with a group of moms who built companies while raising kids. It was a great reminder that I’m not alone.

Of course, as soon as I got on the plane yesterday, my daughter fell at a birthday party and fractured her arm. My husband and kids spent the whole afternoon in the ER getting x-rays and a cast.

As a mom, it always feels like these things happen the second you leave on a trip. I’m feeling a whole range of things: guilt that I’m not there, stress for my daughter and for my husband, who’s overwhelmed, and conflict about being away when my family needs me.

But having a career that gives me meaning and purpose is a critical part of who I am. Balancing that with being a mom was always how I wanted to live my life. It still is. That means sometimes things don’t go according to plan. Sometimes you scrap your plans and get home early. Other times you can lean on your partner and childcare so you can keep going, which is what I’m doing today. I’m really grateful for that support.

I am leaving right after my talk tomorrow morning, though. I’m on a panel about biomarkers and longevity with the founder of Everly Health. Then I’ll race to the airport and switch planes (which I try never to do) so I can get home. It’ll be midnight on Tuesday, but I’ll wake up with my kids on Wednesday morning.

I’ll be extra tired. So I’ll make up for it with extra creatine, extra coffee, and a few minutes on Wednesday to reset my nervous system with a meditation or some light yoga. When I make choices like this, the only way I can keep going is to balance all that effort and stress by restoring my nervous system when I need it. I’m building that into my plan this week.

I’m also skipping alcohol here. HLTH is a big drinking event, and it takes place in a casino. Skipping alcohol is how I sleep well and hold on to as much energy as possible.

And I go to Whole Foods the second I land to stock up:

  • macadamia nuts
  • Epic beef jerky
  • sprouted almonds
  • steamed shrimp
  • Loonen bottled water
  • honeydew melon
  • an organic cold brew

I take everything out of the hotel fridge, put my stuff in, and restock their things when I leave. These little things make such a difference. They keep me in my groove and protect my energy, my digestion and my sleep. And they help me recover quickly when I get home.

I wouldn’t change my life for anything. I choose this. But I also make choices along the way that make it all doable on my terms.

One more thing...

Our Black Friday sale is on! At Parsley, we map your symptoms, cycle and labs to figure out which phase you're in, then build a hormone plan that changes as you do. Get $150 off our functional medicine program with the code BFCARE150.

Stay strong, stay curious, and breathe,
Robin

Originally published in the Off Script newsletter. Join Robin’s readers for weekly functional medicine insights.
As always, this newsletter is for informational and educational purposes only and is not intended as medical advice. Always consult your healthcare provider before making any health decisions or changes to your treatment plan.
Continue with Off Script

Get Robin’s phased HRT plan

Join free to continue reading and receive Robin’s weekly Off Script newsletter on hormones, longevity and evidence-based health.